December 10, 2024

Why Impostor Syndrome Hits Creatives the Hardest (And How to Overcome It)

Picture this: you’ve just completed a design project. The client is thrilled, the feedback is glowing, and yet, a voice inside you whispers, “They’re just being nice. You’re not really that good.”

That voice? It’s impostor syndrome—a psychological phenomenon that makes capable, talented people feel like frauds. For creatives, whose work is deeply personal and often subject to subjective opinions, impostor syndrome hits particularly hard.

But what exactly is impostor syndrome, and how can we combat it? Let’s dive into the facts and strategies to overcome this common struggle.

What Is Impostor Syndrome?

The term "impostor syndrome" was first coined in 1978 by psychologists Dr. Pauline Clance and Dr. Suzanne Imes. It refers to the internal experience of believing that you’re not as competent as others perceive you to be, despite evidence of your skills and accomplishments.

According to a 2020 review in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, impostor syndrome is surprisingly common, with up to 82% of people experiencing it at some point in their lives. It’s particularly prevalent among high-achievers and those in creative industries, where success often feels subjective and fleeting.

Key Signs of Impostor Syndrome:

  • Attributing success to luck or external factors rather than your abilities.
  • Fear of being "found out" as a fraud.
  • Difficulty accepting praise or positive feedback.
  • Overworking to compensate for perceived inadequacy.

If these resonate with you, know that you’re not alone—and you’re not imagining things.

Learn more about impostor syndrome here.

Photo by Antoni Shkraba

Why Creatives Are More Prone to Impostor Syndrome

1. Creativity Is Personal

Every project, design, or illustration carries a piece of its creator. When your work is critiqued, it often feels like a critique of you, making it harder to separate your self-worth from your output.

2. The Subjectivity of Success

In the creative world, there’s no universal metric for success. A project that one client loves might leave another indifferent. This constant ambiguity can chip away at confidence.

3. The Comparison Trap

With platforms like Instagram, Behance, and Dribbble showcasing the “highlight reels” of other creatives, it’s easy to feel like your work doesn’t measure up.

Photo by Manav Sharma

4. The Self-Taught Stigma

As someone who’s self-taught, I know how tough it can be to prove your worth in a world that often values credentials over talent. This lack of formal validation can make impostor syndrome even more pronounced.

The Psychological Impact

Unchecked impostor syndrome can lead to anxiety, burnout, and even depression. A 2019 study published in Frontiers in Psychology found a strong link between impostor syndrome and poor mental health outcomes, including heightened stress and reduced job satisfaction.

If you’re struggling, seeking support from a mental health professional can be a game-changer. Organizations like BetterHelp and Psychology Today offer resources to connect you with licensed counselors who understand these challenges.

Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko

How to Overcome Impostor Syndrome as a Creative

1. Acknowledge It

The first step to overcoming impostor syndrome is recognizing it for what it is: a psychological pattern, not a reflection of reality.

2. Track Your Wins

Keep a “success folder” with positive client feedback, completed projects, and milestones you’re proud of. When doubt creeps in, revisit these reminders of your abilities.

3. Limit Social Media Comparisons

Remember, social media shows the polished highlights, not the struggles behind the scenes. Unfollow accounts that make you doubt yourself and focus on your unique journey.

4. Reframe Self-Doubt

Instead of thinking, “I’m not good enough for this project,” try, “This project will challenge me and help me grow.” Self-doubt can be a sign that you’re stepping outside your comfort zone—a key ingredient for growth.

5. Talk About It

Impostor syndrome thrives in silence. Sharing your experiences with trusted peers or mentors can help normalize these feelings and remind you that you’re not alone.

Photo by Darya Sannikova

Why Impostor Syndrome Can Be a Strength

Yes, you read that right. Impostor syndrome can have a silver lining. Feeling like you have something to prove often pushes you to strive for excellence, learn more, and refine your craft. Many successful creatives admit they’ve felt like impostors at some point—but they didn’t let it hold them back.

The key is to channel that energy into growth rather than letting it paralyze you.

Photo by Michael Burrows

Conclusion

Impostor syndrome is a struggle, but it’s one you can overcome. By recognizing its patterns, celebrating your achievements, and seeking support when needed, you can start rewriting the narrative in your head.

For creatives like us, it’s important to remember: your work matters, your talent is real, and the world needs your unique perspective. The next time self-doubt sneaks in, remind yourself—you’re not a fraud. You’re a creative force, and the world is better for what you bring to it.

If impostor syndrome is affecting your mental health, consider reaching out to a professional or exploring the resources shared in this article. Because taking care of your mind is the first step to nurturing your creativity.